Last Sunday a man strode by me on Bridge Street with a riot of colour and widespread wings on his shoulder. He was taking his great macaw, of scarlet, indigo and gold plumage, for a stroll. Happily, it was a mild day. “He does not like the cold,” the man told a passerby who asked about the parrot. Man and bird looked absolutely companionable.
I was reminded of the parrot who features strongly in Iris Murdoch’s The Book and the Brotherhood. A small African Grey enters the life of eleven-year-old Gerard Hernshaw when clients of his father’s leave the country and cannot take the bird with them. Gerard falls “instantly and passionately” in love with the parrot, whom he names Grey. Its very presence in the house makes him feel he is waking up every day to a miracle. He delights in Grey’s grace and good health, his clever yellow eyes and his pure pale grey feathers with a touch of scarlet in his tail and wingtips.
Gerard adds to Grey’s musical repertoire – he can already perform “Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring” and “Londonderry Air” with his flutelike whistle – teaching him “Three Blind Mice” and “Greensleeves.” Gerard’s mother and thirteen-year-old sister Patricia soon lose interest in the parrot and his care is left to the very attentive Gerard and his father. As the months pass and the bond grows stronger, Gerard has no doubt that Grey returns his affection. He sees in the bird’s eyes “fearless faith and love.” Out of his cage, Grey would lean his soft head on Gerard’s cheek or climb on the back of his neck and peer around so that they were eye to eye. The boy would often nestle the bird against his chest, inside his shirt. He stroked Grey’s feathers while the bird’s claws gripped his fingers “with perfect trust.”
Unfortunately. family dynamics begin to threaten Grey and Gerard’s unfailing delight in one another. Gerard’s mother is annoyed by the occasional bird droppings on the carpet, and she and Patricia find Gerard’s ceaseless talk of Grey’s acrobatic and musical achievements tiresome. Patricia begins to tease Grey, offering him food and then snatching it away. Predictably, he one day bites her finger. Once the furore dies down, Patricia avoids Grey altogether.
It is at this point that Gerard is due to go away to boarding school. He takes a poignant farewell of Grey, pressing his face against the bars of the cage and assuring him he will be back before too long. All his letters home mention Grey and ask that they pass on his love to his treasured bird. When the much-longed-for half-term break at last arrives, Gerard rushes into the house for his reunion with Grey. He runs first into the study, then into the drawing room and then the kitchen. Nowhere can he find Grey.
He screams as his parents explain the parrot has gone to a good home. They tell him it had been too difficult for them to look after Grey with Gerard away at school, and that the bird had become vicious and had bitten Gerard’s mother. At this account, in which he senses deliberate untruths, Gerard has a fit of hysterics that lasts ten minutes. He then falls silent and does not speak to any member of the family for two full days. He emerges from this self-imposed retreat, with his usual cheerful outlook and never mentions Grey again. His mother is relieved the matter is apparently behind them.
Gerard’s father, however, is grievously aware of how badly he has failed his son. He had allowed his wife and daughter to bully him into giving Grey away. This weakness and duplicity deeply wound Gerard. He had believed absolutely in his father’s goodness and fairness, a conviction now tainted by betrayal. When, many decades later, his father dies, Gerard chafes at the fact he had never broached the possibility of forgiveness. Instead, he had maintained a slightly cool demeanour in all their exchanges.
Throughout his adult life, Gerard continues to think of Grey. Given parrots’ longevity, he knows that the bird is probably still alive. He hopes that wherever he is, he is well cared for and happy. But their separation remains a source of anguish. If parrots come up in conversation with friends, Gerard swiftly changes the subject.
There comes a day when Gerard sees a parrot in the window of a pet shop that looks remarkably like Grey. They gaze at each other, the parrot attentive, head to one side and one foot raised. Iris Murdoch describes Gerard’s melancholic regard of the bird as “a reverent, humble stare as if the parrot were some sort of small god.” At the same time he wants to say he is sorry, and even murmurs this aloud. He supposes he means he is sorry that the parrot is captive in a London shop and not flying free in a central African rainforest.
The softly falling snow seems to seal Gerard and the parrot into a private place of ritual. He thinks of his father as he looked on the day of his death, frail and defeated. He thinks again of all that was unsaid between them and the affection he ought more fully to have expressed. He wonders if the dead can know in some way that we love them. As he forms these thoughts, he lifts his hands unconsciously toward the cage in the window. This was the motion he so often performed as a boy when he was about to open Grey’s cage and put his hand in so that the bird could climb onto his fingers and grip them with his delicate claws. As Gerard relives lifting Grey from his cage and cradling him against his chest, tears come to his eyes.
As if the parrot understands his grief, it begins to move from foot to another, spreading its wings to reveal the great fan of grey and scarlet feathers. The bird then closes its wings and regards Gerard out of its wise yellow eyes. Next, exactly as Grey used to do, it takes the bar of the cage in its beak, turns upside down and clambers all over the inside of the cage, while keeping its eyes fixed on Gerard.
There is an instant when he is tempted to go into the shop and buy the parrot. But the parrot is not Grey and his domineering sister and her husband have recently moved in with Gerard, undermining his quiet domesticity. In a gesture tantamount to a blessing, he presses his hand against the glass near the parrot’s head and goes on his way.
As a reader, I felt a pang of regret at Gerard’s decision not to buy this African Grey. Yet what Iris Murdoch achieves in the novel’s concluding pages is a visionary return of Grey in a wholly transformative guise. Gerard has at this point in the story been brought near despair by the accidental shooting death of his dear university friend Jenkin. They had shortly before Jenkin’s demise made plans to live and travel together. Gerard now feels his life to be without purpose, and his former career in the civil service a waste of his abilities. Then he reads the “Book” of the novel’s title, the one the brotherhood of old Oxford friends, including Gerard, had enabled the brilliant, yet dangerous David Crimmond to write. After many years of subsidizing Crimmond’s project, the friends had begun to fear the book would be a ranting Neo-Marxist tract with few redeeming features.
In truth, what Gerard finds in Crimmond’s book is a work of dazzling thought that brings in the whole history of philosophy and envisions a new Utopia. He is moved, in his excitement at Crimmond’s intellectual feat, to write a book of his own in keeping with the ideals instilled in him at Oxford by his revered Classics tutor. He wants to do his utmost “to get the truth clear”, as once he had struggled to get clear the meaning of a difficult Greek text.
He desires again to be confronted “with an impossibly high standard,” and recalls the words of the poet Paul Valéry his tutor used to quote: “a difficulty is a light, an insuperable difficulty is a sun.” It is in fact this aphorism of Paul Valéry’s that serves as the epigraph of Iris Murdoch’s own philosophical work, Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals, a book concerned with the absolute values that are equally Gerard’s focus.
In Gerard’s final scene in the novel, he has a dream of an angel descending toward him in the shape of a great grey parrot. Then he sees the parrot is perched on a book, and “it spread out its grey and scarlet wings and the parrot was the book.”
Of the many bonds of friendship and love depicted amongst the characters in The Book and the Brotherhood, Gerard’s with Grey is the most tender and perfect. His love for his parrot exemplifies the value Iris Murdoch esteemed above all others: the Platonic Eros where we lose all sense of self in our attentiveness to another being. She conceived of this Eros as a continual operation of spiritual energy, capable of making our world more compassionate and more just. These are the enduring values for which we yearn, as Gerard did for Grey, lifelong and unwavering.